Meet Our Team



                                                               Tammy Grogan

    Tammy Grogan is a longtime resident of Summit and Stark Counties; with a deep love of the area she has called home for over forty years. Having raised a family in Stark County, Tammy believes your community is an extension of your family.

    Tammy has been a licensed real estate professional for 30 years and is currently ranked in the top 1% of all registered agents in Ohio for sales. She is the recipient of Cutler Real Estate’s Pinnacle Award for sales volume and was named Cutler Real Estate’s #1 Sales Producer in Ohio. As an advocate for both buyers and sellers, Tammy services most of Northeastern Ohio, and provides her clients with a superior home buying or selling experience.

    In her time outside of work, Tammy enjoys the great outdoors and is an active boater and hiker. She also enjoys visiting her daughter, Ashley, in North Carolina, and son Michael, in New York.








    Abbey Jagger
    Buyer’s Agent 

    Abbey has been an essential member of the team for many years. The Grogans have known Abbey since she was an infant and they knew that her hard working attitude would be the perfect addition to their team. Abbey has been on the team for over three years, and has had great success as a buyers agent. She’s friendly, reliable, fun to be around, approachable…you get the idea. 

    When Abbey isn’t on appointment or helping one of her many buyers, she’s spending time with her family, husband Jeremy—her high school sweetheart—, her new son Jett and two dogs, Ajax and Bentley. She values family and has always understood how important those relationships are. Abbey is very active in her church at Evermore Community Church and helps lead a young married bible study. Her other hobbies include being outdoors running, hiking and playing sports, and traveling around the world with Jeremy. Born and raised in Hartville, Ohio, she’s a Lake girl for life.






    Jen Zeiger
    Buyer’s Agent

    Graduating from Kent State University with a BFA in Jewelry Metals in 2005, Jen launched herself into a jewelry making career and eventually opened up a store with her mom in 2007. After taking time off to raise her two children, she was longing for the human interaction she missed from working with people daily. When Jen and her Husband, Josh, purchased their home from Tammy it sparked a conversation about becoming involved in real estate. She is currently a licensed Buyer’s Agent on our team.

    Jen’s patient, laid back, easy to talk to attitude may make you think she’s calm and quiet, but her work ethic is anything but. She does everything she possibly can to make her clients buying and selling process as stress free and fun as she can.

    Born and raised in North Canton, Ohio, she chose to stay here and raise her young family in the town she loves. When Jen isn’t negotiating contracts or showing homes, you can find her outside in her garden, hiking, and spending time with her family. 




                                                                      Mendee Burnside
    Buyer’s Agent


    Mendee has enjoyed being a long time resident of North Canton with her husband Jarrett and daughter Rae.  When she is not selling real estate she enjoys being active outside, traveling, working in the garden, and is an umpire for girls softball.

    Mendee is a graduate of The University of Akron with a Bachlor’s degree in Fashion Merchendising and an Associate’s degree in Marketing and Sales. Prior to becoming a Realtor, she worked in sales and managment in the healthcare industry for 9 1/2 years.







    Thea Mottice
    Buyer’s Agent

    Thea Mottice has been around Real Estate since 1991. She and her husband Michael were a team in the 90’s. Following the market crash she decided to pursue other interests, during that time she opened an in-home daycare center. This allowed her to stay home and watch her youngest son Zander grow up. Thea missed the office and has worked as an administrative assistant for Realtors for the past five years. She could not be more excited to have gotten her license again. She has a knack for customer service and will not stop until her customers have found the perfect home.

    Thea has been married for thirty years to her high school sweetheart Michael. They raised 5 beautiful children at Lake Mohawk before moving to East Sparta. On days off, Thea can be found working in the yard, taking her dog Reese for a walk, or being at home with her grandsons.






    Caitlin Mitchell
    Buyer’s Agent

    Born and raised in Alliance Ohio, Caitlin has a passion for people. She enjoys all things outdoors, anything sports, and has a love for animals. When not working you can find her spending time with her family, painting and restoring furniture, and finding a good bargain! A soon to be mom, Caitlin is starting her new career as a Real Estate Agent, and is very eager to help potential buyers find their forever home.

    Caitlin has been married since 2014 to her high school sweetheart. She is a graduate of The University of Akron, and has an associates degree in Criminal Justice Technologies. She has been in and around real estate since 2013 and is excited to be learning another side of the business.






    Wendy Grable
    Buyer’s Agent

    As a lifelong resident of Stark County, Wendy’s love of real estate started at a very young age. While still in grade school, she would help her father at his Uniontown real estate brokerage by cleaning, filing, writing new listings and sales on the board, going to open houses and auctions, and often riding along to the board of realtors to pick up the new MLS catalog every two weeks and then excitedly study each page and listing carefully on the drive home. Wendy is a third generation realtor following in her grandfather, father’s, uncles’ and cousins’ footsteps.

    Mom to two boys, Chayce and Tre’, she hopes to one day to see one or both of her boys carry on the family tradition. Until then, she loves to watch them enjoy their many activities at school (Wendy’s alma mater), as well as soccer, Taekwondo (Chayce is a black belt), chess club, art classes (Tre’s favorite), piano lessons, indoor fort building, hiking and playing with the family dog, Violet, two cats, Thomasina and Jinx, and two fish, Thomas and James (yes, there is Thomas the Train theme thanks to Tre’). When not helping clients before, during and after the home buying experience, or taking her boys to their many activities, Wendy enjoys time with family and friends (most of which share friendships of 40+ years), hiking, playing cards, taking trips to museums, zoos and parks with her boys, attending concerts and plays, gardening, home improvement projects and travel.

    Wendy has a dual degree in Business Management and Sales Marketing with 30+ years in retail management and private business ownership and has been a licensed real estate agent with Cutler Real Estate since 2013. During her first year selling real estate, Wendy had the distinction of being awarded the Ohio Association of Realtors Presidents Club, an honor held by less than 3% of Ohio realtors. Wendy’s lifelong experience, knowledge of the surrounding counties and desire to help each client find the home that best suits their individual needs makes her uniquely qualified to help you find your next home!


                                                                Susan Quilter
                                                                Buyer’s Agent

    A native of northeast Ohio, Susan was born and raised in Stark County. She has a long-standing appreciation for the community having owned homes in Louisville, North Canton, Jackson Township and Canton, as well as Canton South.

    Susan also raised her family in the area. She stayed home for 20+ years raising four children and couldn’t be more excited about having her first grandchild.

    Once she hung up her “Mom on Call” status, Susan went back to school and earned a degree from Stark State. She worked as a medical coder for Aultman Hospital before transitioning into a new role at AultCare. It was at this point that Susan had her eye on real estate.

    Susan has been a longtime friend of Tammy Grogan’s and utilized her team to sell her last home. After experiencing the professionalism and quality of Tammy Grogan & Associates at Cutler Real Estate, Susan was motivated to join the team. It is truly a team where clients become friends.





                                                                Nicole Burke
                                                                Buyer’s Agent

    Nicole has resided in Northeast Ohio all of her life. She currently lives in Stark County with her husband Ryan and three beautiful daughters. Nicole and Ryan just celebrated their 20th wedding anniversary!

    Nicole got her Real Estate license in 2006 and helped her family and friends find their dream homes. Nicole recently made the decision to make this her full-time position and is so excited to have the opportunity to assist new buyers find their forever home.  Nicole’s passion beyond Real Estate are volunteering to help the homeless and less fortunate. She is a board member for the Akron Snow Angels.

    When Nicole isn’t selling homes or volunteering you can find her in the gym, cheering on her daughter’s basketball and volleyball teams, and rooting for Hoban – her husband’s football team. When the weather is nice you might find her on a trip to the beach or the golf course. Nicole’s family also opens up their home to foreign exchange students. She loves having a busy home full of fun and even the occasional food or glitter fight!

    Nicole’s easy-going personality and professionalism make her a wonderful addition to the team and a great choice for your buyer’s agent.






    Jessica Storad
    Client Services and Closing Coordinator

    Jessica loves everything she has learned about the business so far. She grew up with real estate agent parents, so it is familiar territory. She is a resident of Barberton with her husband Martin, their dogs Benjamin and Cooper, cat Douglas, and gecko Watson. When she is not at work, she is feverishly working to make their newly bought house into a home.

    Jessica is a graduate of Long Island University, where she studied acting. She has held several jobs in theaters in PA and NYC. She also worked in the kitchen of Cibos Italian Restaurant for 10 years, but feels more comfortable than ever in her office at Cutler. She loves the fast pace and also that no two days are ever the same.







                                                               Heather Schopp
                                                               Marketing Coordinator

    Heather came to our team as a real estate agent but transitioned to Listing Coordinator at the beginning of 2018 and is now excited to be shifting focus to Marketing Coordinator in 2019.

    “2018 was an amazing year! I grew in all aspects of my life. I truly enjoyed my title as Listing Coordinator; meeting and establishing relationships with our sellers and helping them through the beginning stages of selling their home. 2019 will be just as exciting moving into marketing. I am very excited to have Laura Lucisano on our team as our new Listing Coordinator. She will be a great asset to our team with her outgoing personality”

    Heather spends her time with her 6 year-old precocious son and their dog Bear. They enjoy riding bikes, going to family events in the Stark County community, and spending time with their wonderful friends and family.








    Laura Lucisano
    Listings Coordinator

    Laura’s life long curiosity with real estate and her outgoing presonality make a perfect fit for the team. After buying and selling homes with Tammy Grogan and seeing the process, I really wanted to be apart of the team. As Listing Coordinator, I look forward  to something new every day and I really enjoy helping clients with the listing process. I am so excited to be apart of such an amazing dedicated team. I am looking forward to what this new chapter has in store.”

    Laura enjoy the great outdoors, reading, traveling, and spending time with her husband, daughter, friends and visiting her son in Arizona.